Initially initiated as a ten-month pilot scheme, Operation Hillmore aimed to explore methods for returning individuals who had arrived in the UK illegally via small boats to France. At the same time, it sought to establish a controlled legal pathway for eligible migrants in France to enter the UK. The pilot was rolled out swiftly and was originally set to conclude on 11 June 2026, although it has since been extended until 1 October 2026.
Evaluation of Pilot Objectives
The inspection focused on whether the pilot was achieving its objectives, the frameworks in place for evaluating its effectiveness, including the identification and application of lessons learned, and the complexities involved in transitioning from a pilot to a fully operational programme.
The findings indicated that the pilot successfully demonstrated that a jointly linked IN and OUT agreement could be established and effectively implemented using existing legal practices. Significant contributors to this success included the prioritisation and allocation of resources to Hillmore within the Home Office, as well as the strong leadership coordinating efforts across the migration and borders system.
Challenges in Measuring Success
However, the inspection revealed that clear criteria for determining the overall success of the pilot were not established at the outset. The pilot’s stated objectives were centred on high-level strategic goals aimed at deterring migrants from utilising small boats, while numerous other influencing factors were at play. This complexity complicates the evaluation of Operation Hillmore’s specific impact on the reduction of small boat arrivals.
Operation Hillmore presents valuable insights that could guide future initiatives within the Home Office. It is imperative that a comprehensive lessons learned exercise is conducted promptly, prior to the reassignment of key personnel.
Recommendations for Future Initiatives
The report outlines three recommendations designed to enhance the design, implementation, and evaluation of future pilots within the Home Office. The inspection report was submitted to the Home Secretary on 16 July 2026, and it is encouraging to note that the Home Office has accepted all three recommendations in full. Progress is already being made towards the implementation of these recommendations.
John Tuckett, Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration
10 November 2026
Report: An inspection of the UK-France Agreement on the Prevention of Dangerous Journeys (Operation Hillmore) (March – June 2026) The Home Office responses to the Independent Chief Inspector’s reports

More Stories
PM Holds Key Meeting with Dutch Prime Minister Jetten on 21 November 2026
UK’s Ambitious NATO Space Launch Initiative Aims for the Stars
UK Condemns Damage to Diplomatic Premises Amid Russian Assaults on Ukraine: Key OSCE Statement